Adding Epicycles



A passage in the Times this week:

Farhadi had asked two Iranian-Americans, Firouz Naderi, a former NASA scientist, and Anousheh Ansari, a tech entrepreneur and the first female space tourist, to represent him at the ceremony. (Naderi said he believed they were chosen to make the point that borders are invisible from outer space.) As Farhadi’s living room in Tehran quieted down, his surrogates in Los Angeles took the stage. He was not there, Ansari explained in a speech written by Farhadi, “out of respect for the people of my country” and the six other nations targeted by Trump’s executive order. By dividing the world into “us” and “our enemies,” the speech continued, Trump was creating “a deceitful justification for aggression and war.” Farhadi’s words were warmly applauded within the Dolby Theater, but the conservative commentariat was less receptive. “We give an Iranian filmmaker an award & he writes us a lecture on our government,” Lauren Cooley, an editor for The Washington Examiner, posted on Twitter. “How about he go lecture his own Iranian leaders?” Cooley and other such pundits may not have realized it, but they sounded like no one so much as their conservative counterparts in Iran, where Farhadi is often accused of pandering to international audiences by presenting an overly negative image of his homeland.

Cooley writes that as though she, or the larger culture she represents, were part of the deliberation process.  There’s a hollowness to this ‘we’ that evokes a deep sort of sadness if one things about it too long.



2019, Daybreak Thematic Index

  1. Equilibriums and Limits [The Atlantic]
    • Carl Schmidt [SEP]
  2. Frum/Bannon Debate [Youtube]
  3. Can Non-Believers and Believers find civic common ground and reduce their differences to managerial decisions?
  4. Instrumental Reason as “Moneyballing” human social reality [The Point]
  5. Is a new generation dealing with “Industrial Society and Its Future”? [Intelligencer][Unibomber Manifesto]
  6. The work of Elizabeth Anderson on doubting the zero-sum orthodoxy between freedom and equality. [New Yorker]
  7. Are free markets “conservative”? Coming right wing civil war over the question? [The Week][The American Mind]
  8. George Packer on “The Corruption of the Republican Party [The Atlantic]
  9. Notes on Toxic Masculinity [LA Times][Aeon][Polity Books]

Round Two

Brandon – ‘Well, if we do this long distance and write a lot of it out then at least my thoughts will be more coherent.’

R.J.- ‘We’ll see.’


Protected: Library

This content is password protected. To view it please enter your password below:

Library Enter your password to view comments.